The New Tsar

The New Tsar: The Rise and Reign of Vladimir Putin
© 2012 Steven Lee Myers
592pages

When the Soviet Union collapsed abruptly at the dawn of the 1990s, the world order changed overnight. Optimists predicted the ‘end of history’.   Such an end wasn’t kind to Russia, which faced a sinking economy,  dysfunctional attempts at democratic governance, and evaporating infrastructure. It could only watch in frustration as its former adversaries in the west made geopolitical moves in its backyard,  like attacking Serbia to help a breakaway province gain independence. That began to change in 2000, however, when a largely unknown spy-turned-administrator became president, and the oil crunch jump-started the Russian economy.  Vladimir Putin has been at the center of Russian politics ever since,  slowly becoming a bête noire to the power-circles in DC and Brussels.    Although his administration was initially known for an imposition of order and a revival of Russian interests abroad,   in twenty years Putin has  become more inflexible and less effective.   The new order has been built around the man, and even if he wanted to leave, it’s an open question as to whether could survive the sudden vacuum.

As a little boy, Vladimir Putin didn’t want to grow up to be a global leader.  He was more interested in being a spy.  He said as much when he walked into a KGB office and asked for employment. While they turned him down — a literal case of don’t call us, we’ll call you — the officer in charge suggested what academic credentials might serve Putin will in the future.  In 1975, the KGB did come a-calling, eventually stationing Putin in Eastern Germany. That’s where Putin was when the Berlin wall fell and the DDR disappeared. With a mob gathering around the Soviet embassy, and no word from Moscow despite repeated signals for instructions, Putin confronted the mob alone.   Myers suggests that that silence from Moscow — the lack of authority in the face of mounting chaos — haunted Putin and strongly influenced his political career.  That career began when the mayor of St. Petersburg needed a liason with the state security forces; from there Putin would become a deputy mayor, and serve two key men so efficiently that at the end of the nineties, he was a deputy in the national government.  A sick and ailing Boris Yeltsin thought his quietly efficient, politically un-connected lieutenant would be an able successor to continue guiding Russia closer toward concord with the west, complete with a growing economy and growing democracy.  Well…nyet.

It is fascinating to learn that Putin’s rise to power came through his decision to support the liberal, democratic forces within Russia, and particularly when he backed the nascent government against an attempted old-order coup.   We in the west tend to think of Putin as more authoritarian and un-democratic, and by our standards he certainly is.  In his twenty-year reign,  regional democracy has faded away, replaced by appointed governors;   at least two dissident journalists have died , and activists who stage protests seem to find security waiting for them before they begin.   Most of the domestic criticism around Putin’s administration erupted during the ‘tandem’ period: the Russian constitution forbids more than two consecutive terms,  but Putin effectively remained in power despite that limitation by stepping down,  championing a supporter as his successor, and then doing much of the same job from a different office for four years, overshadowing his official boss.  When Putin re-assumed the presidency, Russians objected to the transparent self-serving operation.

I read this primarily to understand more about Russia and the west’s inability to maintain any kind of amicable relationship.  Both American presidents covered in this book approached  Putin hoping for amity and a reset, but each sides’ foreign adventures have undermined those efforts.  Russia’s attempts to maintain its influence in Crimea and the Ukraine, resisting the  latter’s courting by the west, have succeeded only in alienating Ukrainians further and making Europe regard Putin with fearful hostility.  The American wars in Iraq and Afghanistan, and western adventures in regime-toppling with subsequent  chaos and monsters like ISIS,  have led Putin to regard the west as irresponsible fools.  As the west continues to try to contain Russia, Russia continues to boil with predictable resentment about being encircled with  bases and missiles.   Over time,  a desire for respect and legitimacy in Putin’s first two terms has slowly grown into a cool contempt —  while Yelstin wanted to move Russia closer towards the west, Putin’s Russia is increasingly removed from it.

The New Tsar is compelling reading for those interested in Russia’s role or the man himself.  Myers  does a fairly good job at keeping himself out of the text and focusing on how the subject himself came to power and how the position has changed both him and Russia.   Putin is not villainized and turned into a monster-in-the-making,  but he isn’t admired either. Instead, readers are allowed to see why different Russians can value Putin’s  emphasis on strength and stability, or lament his lack of support — and resistance to —  democracy.    Putin has indicated as recently as May 2018 that he plans to step down as president in 2024,     but  his quarter-century of power will cast a long shadow over where Russia goes from there — even assuming he doesn’t exercise influence from semi-retirement, a grey eminence pulling the strings from behind the curtain.  He is a figure well worth understanding.

About smellincoffee

Citizen, librarian, reader with a boundless wonder for the world and a curiosity about all the beings inside it.
This entry was posted in Reviews, Uncategorized and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

11 Responses to The New Tsar

  1. CyberKitten says:

    The first of my long promised Russia books has finally made it to my read next pile. Much more to come on *that* subject!

  2. Brian Joseph says:

    I really should read this. Putin is a figure of great fascination and is clearly playing an important part in our world. I know that Gary Kasparov also has written a book on the man but I believe that is more of a scathing critique of him.

  3. Mudpuddle says:

    this sounds like a must-read book. actually, i don't want to know too much about this era: it's quite depressing and i'm too aged to be able to do anything about it so snail-like, i retire into my shell… i vote, tho: every citizen should be required to do that…

  4. Stephen says:

    Yep! He is…not a fan.

  5. Stephen says:

    I'm in a Russian mood at the moment as well! Finished watching War and Peace with Audrey Hepburn and Peter Fonda last night..

  6. Stephen says:

    I just read an amusing if cynical quote today…”No matter who you vote for, the government always gets in.”

  7. Marian H says:

    This biography sounds pretty in-depth. Putin gives the aura of being totally in charge… is that really the case, or does he also have some kind of committee behind him, like Xi's politburo? Is there no one hovering around him, constantly challenging him? (Maybe I should read the book, haha.)

  8. Stephen says:

    Myers doesn't elaborate on the structure of the Russian government at length. In the beginning Putin relied on a council which Myers refers to as the judocracy, because the men on it had been Putin's judo-training friends. According to Myers, political checks gave way fairly early — institutions like the Duma were either passive, impotent, or supportive. I'm currently looking at a book called “The Limits of Partnership” that examines foreign relations more at length, but I'm not sure of a good source for domestic investigation. Maybe “Putin Country”..

  9. Marian H says:

    “Judocracy”, lol… I'll have to look into “Putin Country”.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s