Nomadland: Surviving America in the 21st Century
© 2017 Jessica Bruder
273 pages

America has always been a nation on the move, but some people take that more literally than others.  Nomadland takes us into the aftermath of the great recession, as the collapse of the housing market and serial firm closures crushed hopes for a secure future and reduced many to poverty.  Some took to the road, and became part of a growing migrant community, of adults who live in vans and RVs and chase seasonal employment, from strawberry harvests in the summer to Amazon holiday crunches in the late fall.  Although not everyone who chooses the Van Life is a victim of the great recession,  Bruder makes that population her focus, with eye-opening results.  

The van life has distinct advantages for those in a bind —  allowing nomads to drastically reduce their expenses, to the point that many become debt free.The constant traveling allows for daily variation, and unique recreational opportunities, including massive rallies and trade meets where RVers and van-dwellers mix with old friends. Against this there are the challenges:   the usual road hazards, of course, in addition to often punishing work, varied as it is. Vehicle breakdowns are far more serious,  as putting a van in the shop means being homeless for a few days.  For those are still financially unstable, a mechanical failure can be catastrophically disruptive.   Although many van-dwellers embrace their status as people who flit on the margins,  bidding a sweet farewell to the rat race and daily tedium,  others regard their transition into the life as a fall from grace.. Particularly sobering, when a reader visits all these stories, is the idea that this kind of poverty can happen to most everyone:   many van-dwellers held very comfortable upper-middle class positions before they encountered disaster.

Nomadland has an entertaining veer-and-lurch narrative: Jessica Bruder desperately wants to write about how the great recession and prolonged economic despair is turning millions of Americans into a perpetual migrant underclass, plug-in workers who appear and disappear at at the convenience of Big Bad Corporations’ logistics departments.  Her particular subjects are foisted into the van and RV life because of financial woes, like the recession or being looted in divorces. Something happens to these people on the road, though, including Bruder’s star subject Linda.  By necessity, they economize and minimize,   and are compelled to focus only on what’s important; the mental fog from day to day distractions disappears.  The same circumstances also compel them to become increasingly self-reliant, as they effect repairs on their own or create workarounds to various problems they encounter. The result is a growing sense of freedom and empowerment: they suddenly become not economic losers, but creative rebels who have  through ingenuity and a willingness to to take chances, found a way to escape the rat race.   Time and again Bruder returns to the poor-victims narrative, only for it derailed by the obvious pleasure and meaning that these migrants are finding in their new life, despite its challenges and difficulties.  

Howevermuch Bruder and her subjects wrestle over the story being told, there’s no denying that Bruder was seriously committed to the work at hand. She spends at least three years engaged in active research, at first living in a tent in migrant communities but then upgrading to a van of her own so she can fully participate in the life.  She knows both the first-timer’s fear at stealth-camping, and the pain of long hours at an Amazon fulfillment center.  Although she most assuredly meets van-dwellers who are markedly different from her, her compassion for the plight of those struggling to recover from setbacks never falters  — and it is that concern that makes her chronic attempts to steer the narrative back to misery and away from  the undeniable freedom these people have found, generally forgivable. Nomadland is absolutely fascinating reading.

About smellincoffee

Citizen, librarian, reader with a boundless wonder for the world and a curiosity about all the beings inside it.
This entry was posted in Reviews, Society and Culture and tagged , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

6 Responses to Nomadland

  1. Marian says:

    This sounds really good. I’ll share it with my mom – she watches these vloggers on YT and has told me some of those stories. We have recurring debates about it…as you implied, it all hinges on whether you think there is a problem with people living this way in the modern day, especially by choice as some do.

    • I watched some van conversion vids last year as an offshoot from a modern minimalism series (I think I was looking for approaches similar to tiny houses). It’s astonishing what people can do! I have a recurring fantasy of taking off and car-camping across the rural US, but the midlife crisis will have to wait until I’ve paid my car off at the very least. :p

      • Marian says:

        Yeah on a certain level it’s definitely appealing! I can’t say there’s much to entice someone to stay in the cities right now.

  2. I have not read this book, but the film version of it starring Frances McDormand in an Academy award-winning performance was stunning. The picture deserved the academy award that it won as well as the award for the director, Chloe Zhao. I think that, for me at least, the “undeniable freedom” and community that the nomads achieve came through in the film. I’m not sure I will take time to read the book.

  3. Pingback: The Warehouse | Reading Freely

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s