Rubbish!

Rubbish! The Archaeology of Garbage
© 1992 William Rathje and Cullen Murphy
250 pages

moo

Given that historians often use the contents of middens to glean information about societies which have long faded away, it’s only fair to see what our present landfills (tomorrow’s middens) have to say about us. Largely, they reveal how little we actually know. “The Garbage Project” both intercepted garbage on its way to transfer stations from various pots in the country, and literally conducted excavations in landfills, and it found much to contradict common knowledge. Biodegradables, for instance, don’t. They don’t degrade. This was initially thought to be because modern dumps are sealed against moisture, but there are examples of marginal degradation well before landfill cells became the norm. Also, many of the favored whipping boys for trash — plastic and diapers — don’t take up nearly the amount of space as people think. The lions of trash, going by the stuff that’s actually in the ground, is paper and construction materials. Throughout the book, there’s hints that studying garbage can tell us the truth about people who lie either to themselves or to surveyors: for instance, one Hispanic neighborhood reported that they almost never used prepared baby food, buuuuuuut the contents of their trash bins determined that was a lie. Amusingly, people across the board underestimate how much unhealthy food they eat, and over-report how much healthy food they eat. The book closes with “10 commandments”, urging people to concentrate on the real offenders (paper and construction materials), realize that there’s no approach to garbage that’s a real solution, that instead we need to use landfills, incineration, recycling, and source reduction in concert, etc. The commandments all very reasonable, sober, and not exciting in the least. They don’t even start with a terribly dramatic opener, like “I AM THE LORD THY GOD, WHO BROUGHT THEE OUT OF EGYPT…”

Bottom line: this informative, sometimes amusing, but often dry.

Related:
Waste and Want, Susan Strasser
Gone Tomorrow: The Hidden Life of Trash.  I’ve read this one, but can’t seem to find the review. Curious!
Picking Up:  On the Streets and in the Trucks with the Sanitation Department of New York City
Garbage Land: On the Secret  Trail of Garbage
Garbology: Our Dirty Love Affair with Trash

Junkyard Planet, Adam Minter

About smellincoffee

Citizen, librarian, reader with a boundless wonder for the world and a curiosity about all the beings inside it.
This entry was posted in Reviews and tagged , . Bookmark the permalink.

10 Responses to Rubbish!

  1. Anonymous says:

    You do have a *thing* about trash/rubbish don’t you…? [grin]. Personally I’m quite getting into Trains and Travel stories these days….. Maybe I just need a proper holiday?

    • I blame SimCity 3000 for making me so keenly interest in garbage and power lines and the goings-on of water pumps!

      Trains and travel doesn’t sound bad at all! Fiction or nonfiction or both?

      • Anonymous says:

        [grin] I know what you mean about SimCity. Sewage never seemed so…. important.

        I found a few authors that seem to specialise in train related historical crime stories which looked like fun. Plus one of them also writes non-fiction train stuff too. The travel books are all non-fiction. Maybe post-retirement I’ll travel the world without leaving my sofa.

      • It’s worse in Cities Skylines…..the mayor also has to make sure dead bodies are picked up for the crematoriums!

  2. Marian says:

    In one paragraph, you’ve destroyed my faith in archaeologists and plant-based sporks… what is left?!

  3. My gag-reflex would not allow me to read this book!

    • Oh, not to worry….there’s not a lot of juicy details, just digging and data.

      • Then I might be fine with it. I’ll have to think about it…that TBR is still going to topple over at some point!

      • Ehh…..it’ not one I’d recommend, necessarily. “The Only Plane in the Sky” is far worthier! :p (I’m reading it now and almost sent you a message on goodreads last night to the effect of “OMG shortlist this”, but I didn’t want to stop reading it. The only reason I stopped and went to bed was because my phone was on 5%, and I never let it get that low.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s