John Grisham: Favorites and Unfavorites

John Grisham was the first novelist whose entire bibliography I ever finished, though these days I must limit that to “adult” biblography, given his kid lawyer series.     Given that there are so many, I thought it would  be fun to list my favorites and unfavorites.   Not mentioned are many in the middlle, of varied quality.  The favorites are in chronological order, and the unfavorites are in stinklist order.    Over the years I’ve tried to re-read Grisham books from before the blog, and  I’ve linked to those with reviews.

 Favorites

A Time to Kill (1989): Grisham’s first novel opens with an outraged father taking justice into his own hands after the men who raped and beat his child are acquitted by a racially biased jury.  The novel was mostly ignored until the success of The Firm gave Grisham real name recognition, but challenges the reader with the question of when it is appropriate to take justice into one’s own hands. 

The Firm (1991): The first Grisham book I ever read, a crime thriller about a young lawyer who is accepted into an elite boutique firm, only to realize a few months in that they’re an organ of the Mafia. 

The Pelican Brief (1992): It’s been a long time since I read this one in high school, but I remember being fascinated by the idea of Supreme Court opinions.  The story tracks a series of deaths related to an explosive briefing about an endangered wetland (I…think?), and involves the New Orleans Mafia.

The Client (1993)   Again, it’s been a long time since I read this one, but the story of a young boy stumbling upon a scene he wasn’t supposed to see, and subsequently becoming an object of interest to both the FBI and the Mafia, protected only by a young attorney who focuses on child abuse,  is unforgettable. (….Grisham wrote quite a few Mafia related books early on,  I’m realizing…)

The Chamber (1994)  The Chamber is easily the most thought-provoking novel I read in high school.  Its plot involves a young lawyer taking on his estranged grandfather — decades lost to  him– as a client.  His  grandfather sits on death row, awaiting execution within the gas chamber after being judged guilty of a bombing which killed two children during the 1960s.   The Chamber is less a legal thriller and more of a novel wrestling with moral themes,  and reckoning with the past.   This novel made me think long and deep about the death penalty in high school, which is more than any bombastic political arguments could have done.

The Rainmaker (1995)  This duels with The Last Juror as my favorite, and it may not be an accident that they’re both first-person novels.   Young Rudy Baylor, a bankrupt law school grad, stumbles upon a gold mine of a case while at a legal clinic. The novel turns into a genuine David vs Goliath story, and has the most comprehensive depiction of a legal trial from soup to nuts I’ve ever encountered.

The Street Lawyer (1998). A prosperous but unhappy big city attorney suddenly finds a way to find meaning in his life when his office is held hostage by a homeless man with a mission.

The Brethren (2000).    I debated including this one on here, because I hate the ending. The setup, though, is fun. Three disgraced judges locked up in a federal pen are using their time in exile to scam up money for themselves by targeting closeted gay men for blackmail. When they accidentally snare a man handpicked by the CIA to be the next president  things get interesting.  I mostly enjoy this one for the execution of the scam; I found the mundane details of how the judges passed messages and money back and forth  interesting.

The King of Torts (2003)    Ah, this one is fun. A young attorney becomes a hotshot multimillionaire when he  is invited into the world of mass torts, but it’s definitely  a rise and fall situation.   The novel is interesting in that while Grisham uses it to talk a little politics — as he usually does —  there’s no hard line here.

The Last Juror (2004).   One of Grisham’s more interesting novels; this one follows a couple of decades in the life of Willie Traynor,  a weekly newspaper publisher, and through his press the life of Clanton, MS as Vietnam and suburbanization set their sights on American small towns.    The story is tied together through a legal case involving a brutal murder, the memory of which keeps revisiting the town.

The Unfavorites

The Associate,  2009.   A rather obvious attempt to make a story out of  the Duke  lacross team scandal, but instead of focusing on that,  Grisham uses it to dive into some conspiracy thriller involving blackmail and defense contracts. I enjoyed it at the time, although the ending was…underwhelming. It has not improved in memory. 

Grey Mountain,  2014.    A premise with great potential is squandered by feckless lead character bobbing around like flotsam in a story that goes nowhere and serves only to bludgeon the reader with a message:  Big Coal is Bad.

The Appeal, 2008.    The first Grisham novel I read and wished I could have the time and money spent on it back.  It’s a depressing tale of a mass tort case and crooked elections.

The Racketeer (2012): a bumbling lawyer who drifts into even more bumbling fraud morphs into a criminal mastermind while in prison,  lying even to the reader.  An unbelievable and obnoxious potboiler.

Rogue Lawyer (2015): nonstop despair, brooding, and violence, with a premise entirely too much like  Connelly’s The Lincoln Lawyer. Easily my most unfavorite, and if it weren’t for the fact that I receive Grisham books as Christmas gifts by people who would be annoyed if I disposed of them, I would have set fire to this one as soon as I read it. Absolutely The Worst. 

 I’m not sure what to make of the fact that I apparently enjoyed Grisham’s earlier works far more than his recent ones.    I’ve changed as a reader, I’m sure,   just as I’m sure Grisham has changed as a writer:  when he releases 1.5 books every year,     a decrease in quality over time isn’t that surprising.  Even if ideas don’t run out, passion can.


About smellincoffee

Citizen, librarian, reader with a boundless wonder for the world and a curiosity about all the beings inside it.
This entry was posted in General, Reviews, Uncategorized and tagged . Bookmark the permalink.

10 Responses to John Grisham: Favorites and Unfavorites

  1. R. T. says:

    If I ever read Grisham, I’ll follow your Rx advice ….

  2. Marian H says:

    I've long wanted to read a Grisham novel; maybe I'll carve out some time this summer. Thanks for the recs (and warnings)!

  3. mudpuddle says:

    i love Perry Mason novels but i've never tried one of these.. maybe i should?

  4. CyberKitten says:

    I think I have one…. somewhere. Not 100% sure though. Can't *remember* ever reading one….. *Think* I've seen some of the movies…. Both books and movies obviously made a DEEP impression on me!

  5. Stephen says:

    His stories cover both thrills and disasters, so I hope you start off with a godo one!

  6. Stephen says:

    They're all mystery-thrillers, so…why not? The Rainmaker is the most solidly legal.

  7. Stephen says:

    My first Grisham encounter was The Rainmaker movie, which was very well done. It stars a young Matt Damon (think Good Will Hunting young) and Danny DeVito, and is the only JG movie I've bought so I could re-watch it. Didn't care for The Firm, The Client, et. al too much. Runaway Jury had a favorite as the baddie, but I don't recall anything about it other than that.

  8. I love this post!! I used to LOVE his novels, but I think the last one I read was The Rainmaker, and then I tried to be interested in the rest but couldn't, so he fell off even earlier for me than he did for you. A Time to Kill and The Client will forever and always be my favorites – both book and movie-wise.

  9. Stephen says:

    I don't remember much about those two movies (except for a cop using 'indigent' like an insult), but The Rainmaker with Matt Damon and Danny DeVito was my introduction to Grisham. It's still one of my favorite movies to this day!

  10. Pingback: Top Ten Books I Read and Read Again | Reading Freely

Leave a Reply to Sarah @ All The Book Blog Names Are Taken Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s