Stoic Warriors

Stoic Warriors: The Ancient Philosophy Behind the Military Mind
© 2005 Nancy Sherman
242 pages

This semester’s schedules give me a lot of gaps between activities that lend themselves well to spending a few moments in the university library, where I do a little reading — or napping, as the case warrants. Here I read books unavailable in the public library system, like Stoic Warriors. I picked this one up out of curiosity and found it quite readable. The author, in her words, “uses the contemporary military as a lens through which to study and assess Stoic doctrine.” The book is divided into seven chapters: “A Brave New Stoicism”, “Sound Bodies and Sound Minds”, “Manners and Morals”, “A Warriors Anger”, “Fear and Resilience”, “Permission to Grieve”, and “The Downsized Self”. There’s no concluding chapter, which I found a bit odd.

The author begins by introducing the reader to Stoicism through the story of James Stockdale, a Vietnam-era P.O.W. who uses Stoicism to help strengthen himself and his fellow prisoners. Here we are introduced to Stoicism’s tenants and its most well-known practitioners: namely Epictetus, who was less concerned with “theory” and more concerned with the practical matter of living and behaving rationally in an irrational world. I’ve been studying Stoicism since the end of last year when I decided to figure out the context of Marcus Aurelius and Epictetus’ works, both of which I’ve read here. There’s a lot to it. I wouldn’t want to try to sum up the whole of the phiolosophy here, but this book is really focused on the more practical side of it, and so that’s what I will comment on. Epictetus said in his Manual for Living that happiness begins with the realization that some things are under our control and other are not — and that we should only be concerned with that which we can control. This is something I realizing myself during the summer, perhaps infering it when I re-read my favorite parts of Aurelius’ Meditations.

The next chapter, “Sound Bodies and Sound Minds”, almost acts as a prolonged introduction in that the author uses body-training disicipline as a way of showing how our rational minds can exert control over our bodies. The same situation provides a warning against valuing disicpline for disicpline’s sake. The next few chapters deal with their titular topics: morals, anger, fear, and so on. The author references Greek literature to provide cultural context while citing generously from Seneca’s plays and the writings of Cicero, Epictetus, and Marcus Aurelius. The author also connects Stoic ideas with other philosophical works of the period and even beyond the period — referencing philosophy from other periods of history. While she is doing all this, she uses examples from the American military to illustrate and point out the usefulness of Stoic ideas (as well as their limitations, particularly in later chapters).

I was impressed with the book. It was an enjoyable read that limited esoteric terminology. It strikes me as well-organized and well-written: definitely worth my time.

Posted in Reviews | Tagged , , | 2 Comments

The Titan’s Curse

The Titan’s Curse
© 2008 Rick Riordian

This week I read book three in the Percy Jackson and the Olympians series, and I must say that this was an improvement over The Sea of Monsters, at least in my estimation. The book gets off to a rough start: the author doesn’t introduce the situation very well, establishing no ties to the ending of the last book so the readers don’t really know what’s going on. The last book saw Zeus’ daughter Thalia rescued from her fate of being a tree. She joins Percy in this newest adventure, which immediately begins by their having to rescue two half-bloods from a school after being attacked by a monster of sorts. If that seems familiar, it’s how the last two books began as well.

Despite this rocky start, the book soon picks up. Trouble is (as usual) brewing. Kronos‘ revival seems to be going well as his armies are growing larger and more dangerous. We’re introduced to several more gods in this book: Artemis, Apollo, and Athena all make extended appearances. (Apollo defends his role as the sun-god while dismissing astronomy as boring. ) Percy, Grover, and Thalia — along with Artemis’ hunters — are tasked with rescuing Artemis from the clutches of Kronos before the Winter Solstice. (Solstice deadlines are also a familiar element of this series.) The story’s plot is also personal for the readers, as one of the other familar characters is placed in jeopardy. The quest takes them to San Francisco, where the citadel of the Titans is being rebuilt. The story is both fun and darkly serious at times. A lot of the drama is self-conflict, as the characters try to deal with the monsters within them.

The book ends with a temporary resolution: the ultimate conflict is still (they think) at least two years away, in which time they will double their training efforts while blocking the Titans’ ascent at every turn. I will be continuing the series.

Posted in Reviews | Tagged , , , , | Leave a comment

Yoda: Dark Rendezvous

Yoda, Dark Rendezvous: A Clone Wars Novel
©
2004 Sean Stewart

The long day of the Republic had come to an end. (Pg. 1)

I’ve been in a Star Wars frame of mind ever since Thanksgiving when I began to anticipate enjoying my Christmas Star Wars viewing. As such, I keep wanting to read more, and so this week I did. As you might surmise from the title, the book is set during the Clone Wars, which began at the end of Attack of the Clones and which concluded at the end of Revenge of the Sith. For the uninitiated, the Clone Wars refer to the war between the Republic and the Confederacy of Independent Systems. The CIS is led by Count Dooku, General Grevious, and (secretly) Lord Sideous. Their armies consist of massive amounts of droids (who are kind enough to provide comic relief before they are destroyed) and odd-looking battle machines that look rather ungainly. The Republic’s armies consists of Clone Troopers, commanded by Jedi knights. Count Dooku was once a Jedi knight, but left the order and now wars against his former brethren.

During a high point of this war, a Jedi escapes from fighting Dooku and one of his force-using minions with a message from Count Dooku. It seems he wants to parley with his former master and seek an end to the war. His former master is Yoda, perhaps best known for hitting R2-D2 with a stick. Yoda is actually one of the more recognizable characters in the Star Wars universe — alongside Darth Vader, I would guesstimate those two are the two most well-known. Yoda, two Jedi knights, and their padawans set off in secret to meet Dooku. Meanwhile, the two young padawans are struggling with self-conflicts. One, Whie, keeps have disturbing dreams that suggest he will turn to the Dark Side, while the other — Scout — copes with being weak in the Force.

Dooku’s plea is of course a ruse, and there’s lot of political intrigue here. The book climaxes on a planet steeped in the Dark Side (there seem to be a lot of those in the Extended Universe), where Yoda and Dooku’s personalities come into conflict — first in discussing their philosophies, and then putting a finer point on said discussion. While the main characters are Yoda, the two Padawans, and Dooku, there are a number of assisting characters. Obi-Wan and Anakin Skywalker appear in the end, and the author weaves in foreboding passages about Anakin’s character. A character from the Clone Wars cartoon series who is Anakin’s arch-nemesis also appears. She’s a Dark Jedi who is not apprenticed to Dooku, but does his bidding in the hopes that he’ll off Sideous and they can rule the galaxy. (Say what you will about Palpatine, but he does realize the “Apprentice someone who will try to kill you” tradition of the Sith does not lend itself well to job security.)

The story is quite interesting, as is the characterization. It’s a worthy addition to the EU universe, but what I really want to compliment is the author’s ability to really give background: we see the Republic changing as the war wears on, in both their view of the Chancellor and of the Jedi. Given the attitudes we witness in this book, it’s not hard to contemplate the public’s lack of response to Order 66. Also, the ongoing discussion of Sith and Jedi philosophy is really intriguing. The author makes insightful comments about human nature through his characters’ discussion of these matters. One quotation I liked was “Loyalty is stronger going up than coming down.” Another — “It’s always so easy to avoid other people’s vices, isn’t it?”

This was an excellent book. I recommend it even over the Darth Bane books, which is saying something given how much I enjoyed them.

Posted in Reviews | Tagged , | 1 Comment

This Week at the Library (19/1)

Books this Update:

  • In the Presence of Mine Enemies, Harry Turtledove
  • Only Begotten Daughter, James Morrow
  • Sway, Ori and Rom Brafman

I began with a return to Turtledove. While I do plan to return to his Colonization series, I read instead this week a standalone book set in the near future, but one shaped by a past different from ours: a past in which the United States remained neutral during the Second World War. Its lack of economic and military aid to Britain and the Soviet Union led to their respective collapses and the domination of the eastern hemisphere by Nazi German, the Italian Empire, and the Imperial Japan. (Want to guess why they own so much sand? There’s black stuff under it.) The United States was attacked a “generation” later with nuclear missiles and essentially knocked out, although we’re given the impression that it was attacked out of fear of its economic potential, not because its leaders were starry-eyed idealists who wanted to rid the world of tyranny and oppression and so forth.

Turtledove likes to lift stories from the history books and retell them in different contexts. In his “Southern Victory” timeline, for instance, we see military campaigns that were in reality executed in 1864 being perpetuated in 1944. Instead of the Holocaust happening in Europe, it happened in the deep south. Turtledove does this again in In the Presence of Mine Enemies, telling the story of the dramatic political change of the late 1980s in the Soviet Union, changing the years and making the evolving political entity the Greater German Reich instead of the SSSR. Within that context, Turtledove uses his traditional viewpoint method to tell the story of various people as they react to these changes. What is particular about these people is that they are all Jews, their genealogies having been forged. It’s an interesting book and has become one of my favorite Turtledove works.

Next I read a work of fantasy in Only Begotten Daughter. This book begins with the idea that a being resembling the Judeo-Christian god magicked up a kid in 1974. Julie Katz, who refers to herself as Jesus’ half-sister, struggles with her nature, the nature of God, and the question of evil while being pursued by Satan and attacked by Christian fundamentalists as the Antichrist. Along the way, she accidentally creates a religion around empiricism and visits Jesus in Hell, where he is occupied in soothing the pains of the damned. The conversation between he and Julie about his life on Earth and the consequences thereof is one of the most interesting parts of the book. The plot is intriguing and the characterization good, but the book was far too dark for my tastes.

Lastly, I read Sway: The Irresistible Pull of Irrational Behavior. In the book, the authors assert that human beings — while pretending to be rational — are really not rational at all, and in fact fall into irrational traps with disturbing ease. They use accounts of seemingly rational people behaving in irrational (and all-too familiar) ways to point out irrational traps. These aren’t obvious things like not questioning beliefs or willfully believing in things with no regard to the evidence, but are rather subtle misdirections, like taking a wrong turn in the house of mirrors. The book is very informal, very readable, and begs me to recommend it — so I do.

Next Update:

  • Dark Rendezvous, Sean Stewart
  • Demon in my View, Amelia Atwater-Rhodes
  • Stoic Warriors, Nancy Sherman
  • The Titan’s Curse, Rick Riordian
Posted in Reviews | Tagged | 1 Comment

Sway

Sway: the Irresistible Pull of Irrational Behavior
©
2008 Ori and Rom Brafman
185 pages, plus notes and an index

I’m not quite sure how I found this one, but it was a fun little read. The authors — brothers — begin by asserting that while we think of ourselves as rational creatures, we’re actually more irrational than we’d like to admit. Even those whose livings depend on them thinking in a rational manner — scientists, for instance — can be trapped into thinking in irrational ways. These “traps” are subtle: people are never really aware of them, hence their danger. Throughout the book, the authors use news events and other examples to show these irrational traps, and then to identify them. The book is very informal and quite readable, as well as thought-provoking. The authors don’t use any complicated terminology, as they might be tempted to were they writing a more serious academic work. Two particular traps they identify — just to whet your appetite — is an obsession with stopping loss. When our plans are thrown off schedule, we tend to do everything in our power to get back on schedule, never taking time to ponder the situation and realize that the effort is perhaps futile. We see various examples of people trying to avoid the loss of time or money, only to lose more time and money in trying to recover their initial losses. One of these efforts ends with the deaths of several hundred people. Another interesting trap is what initial appearances do for us.

This book is a very interesting read, and I recommend it. The book doesn’t seem to have a lot of structure to it, though: you won’t find any neat introductions and summaries like in Shermer’s Why People Believe Weird Things. Even so, it’s an enjoyable read.

Posted in Reviews | Tagged , | Leave a comment

Only Begotten Daughter

Only Begotten Daughter
© 1990 James Morrow
296 pages

A few weeks ago I heard of an interesting book: the story of a child of God, miraculously conceived similar to the story of Jesus. This child is born in 1974, in Atlantic City. Unlike her half-brother Jesus, Julie Katz — the only begotten daughter — was not born of a virgin. She appeared in a sperm bank, a miraculous conception of a far less mystic sort. Fortunately the people of the sperm bank had an “ectogenesis machine”, a mechanical womb. When Murray Katz — her father, God being the “mother” — finds out that they plan on terminating the fetus, he opts to steal the ectogenesis machine with his daughter inside. Fortunate timing, for soon after the sperm bank would be destroyed by Christian fanatics intent on bringing about the Endtimes — fundamentalists referred to as Revelationaists.

Murray lives by himself at an abandoned lighthouse and raises little Julie there. He is not entirely alone: a quirky woman named Georgina who he met at the sperm bank helps him. She, too, has a child. Her daughter (Phoebe) and Julia grow up together with their very eccentric parents. There are few “normal” people in this book: all of the characters we encounter are bizarre in some way or another. Julie quickly exhibits signs of her divinity — walking on water, for instance. Murray, realizing how quickly attention will be drawn to her and how dangerous that might be, trains her not to use her divine powers. In this first part of the book, Julie struggles with both her identity as the daughter of God and with the problem of evil. She creates a temple out of one of the rooms in the lighthouse and fills it with clippings of all of the human misery in the world, in an effort to show herself that were she to take the “high road”, she would overwhelmed and consumed at the task. The struggle between the “high road” — using her powers for good — and the low road, or simply living her life, will preoccupy her for a good bit of the book. She attracts the attention of Satan, who plays mind games with her. At the same time, the Revelationists are increasing in numbers and in their activities, and they will force Julie’s hand. The story takes Julie to Hell, where she meets her half-brother Jesus (occupied with offering relief to the tortured) and then back to Earth.

Along the way, the author pokes around at the question of evil and the idea of intelligent, or even beneficiant, design. Julie is convinced that her mother is not a Zeus-type being that meddles in human affairs, but rather a God of physics: part of the fabric of the universe, too broad to be articulated in human affairs. Satan seems to be portrayed as somewhere between the Jewish idea of Satan and the Christian idea of Satan. In Judaism (as far as I know), Satan is a loyal servant of God who tempts humans in order that they might grow. In Christianity, he’s arrogant, vain, rebellious, and spiteful. In this book he delights in evil and pain, but speaks of God in the manner of a contemptuous subordinate. Hell exists, with islands for the various wrong-doers (there’s an Island of Methodists, an Island of Atheists, and so on). The author employs a lot of Biblical allusions, especially after Julie meets Jesus. (That particular scene is amusing: Julie has to explain Christianity to an unbelieving Jesus, who was quite sure he tried set up a godly and ethical kingdom on Earth, only to be killed for his efforts: he had no intention of establishing a religion and had never heard of original sin. “Good heavens, is that what I became? Another propitiation deity?”

The characterization is good, and the story dark and interesting. It was a bit too dark for me, though. I liked the satirical bits, and the effort by the author to explore the ideas of evil and cosmology in this context. The character of Jesus is refreshing: I was raised a Christian but the guy never appealed to me. He’s a much more attractive character in this book: the author makes him more human and more “divine” than all of the gospels did, and in just a few pages.

All in all, a rather interesting story. He’s written more that interest me — Towing Jehovah, for instance, a story of what happens after God dies — but I don’t have access to them.

Posted in Reviews | Tagged | 2 Comments

In the Presence of Mine Enemies

In the Presence of Mine Enemies
©
Harry Turtledove 2003
515 pages

This week I returned to Turtledove, but not quite yet to the Colonization series. This week I read In the Presence of Mine Enemies, a standalone book set in the early 21st century. The year is never mentioned, but it is after 2003: Leni Riefenstahl is mentioned as having died and at over a hundred years of age. She was born in August 1902 and (in reality) died in September 2003. The setting is the Greater German Reich: this is a work of alternate history wherein the Second World War wasn’t quite a world war. The United States never became involved, for reasons I don’t recall being explained in the book. Without its industrial support of Great Britain and the Soviet Union, and without its intervention in the Pacific (apparently) , Nazi Germany and Imperial Japan were able to run willy-nilly around the globe creating empires for themselves. A “generation later”, the United States was attacked with nuclear weapons, defeated, and partially occupied but not annexed by the Greater German Reich.

Contrary to the idea that the Cold War alone fueled the space age, Germany has a space program — one advanced and funded enough to the point that an observatory is on the moon and a mission to Mars has been launched. Were I to speculate at the why of this, I would say it’s an attempt at self-glorification by the Nazis. Turtledove tells his story through the eyes of various viewpoint characters, which is a common method for him. In his serials, the dozen or so viewpoint characters cover a wide range of types — from world leaders to housewives. Here, though, we only have six viewpoint characters, and they’re all in the same relative class of Germany: middle-middle class. One is a university instructor, one a computer engineer, and another one of the Reich’s accountants. This is a story about Germany, and so all characters are German — but they have something else in common. In the opening chapter, Heinrich Gimpel — the aforemntioned accountant — heads home after work to attend his daughter’s coming-of-age birthday party. After the fesitivities, Alicia is told that she is not like most subjects of the Reich: she is a Jew.

Despite the Holocaust, a remnant of European Jewry has survived, in hiding in plain sight. With forged geneologies, several families of Jews remain living in the heart of Germany, Berlin. (Interestingly, although Berlin does gain the hubristic monuments that Hitler planned, it has apparantly survived his intention to destroy and rebuild it block by block with a “new vision” and with the new name of Germania, as the History Channel informs me he did.) In the Presence of Mine Enemies is the story of the remaining Jews in Berlin and how another story — political changes in the Reich — change them. At book’s beginning, the Reich is as severe as depicted in various police-state novels and movies. The NSDAP controls everything, relying on fear, power, and romantic appeals to the Volk to keep the populance in order. The current Fuhrer is Kurt Haldweim, a dinosaur of the old guard. He will die shortly into the book, and the Powers that Be’s search for a new Fuhrer begins a period of political turmoil in the Reich that will have consequences for everyone. Meanwhile, the Jews hide in plain sight: the males go uncircumsized, adults only tell their children when they’ve reached a more responsible age, and those in the know only practice parts of their traditions, most of it being lost. Their libraries are stocked with the same antisemetic literature that every Nazi household has. Somehow, even though the children are only told this when they’re older (I suspect around the time of bar/bat mitzvahs), this doesn’t hinder their ability to suddenly believe in YHWH and that they’re part of a special breed of humans. I find this hard to believe, and was disapointed by the utter credulity of the “Jewish” children depicted in the book.

Turtledove likes to weave real historical events into his alternate history stories: writing the event in but with different characters. For instance, in his “Southern Victory” series, we see the Holocaust happen in the Confederacy, not Europe. In Worldwar, Lizard planes attack Schweinfurt and encounter the same tough resistance. I don’t know why he does this: perhaps out of amusement, perhaps because it’s the easiest thing to sell to a mass audience. Here he does the same thing. The new Fuhrer is Germany’s Gorbachev, and the analogy goes on. A possible Yeltsin figure appears, but without a sequel I can’t be sure. What happens is riveting reading.

This was a truly enjoyable book. I’ve only read two other Turtledove standalones, but I think this is the best so far. It beats the Worldwar series, and perhaps what I’ve read of the Colonization series. It’s a thoughtful (in most parts) story in an interesting setting, telling a familar story in another context. If he wrote a sequel to this, I would be interested in reading what happens.

Posted in Reviews | Tagged , | 2 Comments

This Week at the Library (11/1)

Books this Week:

My reading this week was fairly light, as I began preparations to return to school — and did, on Friday. I began by continuing in Rick Riordian’s Percy Jackson and the Olympians series with The Sea of Monsters. In the last book, we were introduced to Percy Jackson, a Hero in the Greek sense: the offspring of a Greek god (in his case, Poseidon) and a mortal. Percy, becoming aware of his status as a hero after repeatedly being attacked by monsters and rescued by a centaur and a satyr, comes to Camp Half-Blood, a sanctuary for demigods like himself. Owing to who his father was, young Percy was caught up in divine politics between the various gods of the Pantheon, giving us our story last time: the thunder of Zeus was stolen, and He blamed it on Poseidon, while both suspect that Hades was orchestrating a frame-up job. In the last book, Percy discovered that the current cause of conflict between the Big Three was really caused by the Titans stirring. The Titans, for those who know little of Greek mythology, were once in charge. Zeus felt his father Kronos was doing a poor job of things, though, so He threw Kronos and all of his siblings into various pits. Well, after a few thousand years of that, Kronos is bored and wants to rise to resume control over the Cosmos (well, Earth) and destroy western civilization, which in his opinion is overrated. In The Sea of Monsters, Kronos‘ attempt to rise is on-going, and again impacting Greek politics. Percy, Annabeth, and the daughter of Ares are tasked with reclaiming the Golden Fleece in hopes of protecting Camp Halfblood while at the same time rescuing Percy’s satyr friend Grover from…getting married? The story is light and fun. This isn’t as good as the first book: there’s less wry commentary on humanity, for instance. It’s still fun, though.

Continuing with the idea of evil rising, I read Darth Bane: Rule of Two — the second in an unfinished Darth Bane trilogy. Last time we were introduced to Darth Bane, a miner turned Sith soldier who attracts the attention of Sith lords and is trained in the Dark Side by the Brotherhood of Darkness. He was repulsed by what he saw as the Brotherhood’s betrayal of Sith ideals and sought his own path. His path happened to involve finding a way to destroy all of heretical Sith and restore the old ways. His quest to realie the fullness of the Dark Side took him to various places, ending on a planet where an army of Jedi and an army of Sith were struggling against one another. The first book ended shortly after he completed his first mission and after he began to rebuild the Sith Order. Rule of Two continues from there, and documents his growth as a Sith Master, his apprentice’s growth in the Dark Side, and Jedi/Republic politics. This book was quite good. It was written in only a few months, but I couldn’t tell. It was a riveting story and I recommend it — to Star Wars fans at the very least.

Lastly, I read Isaac Asimov’s Atom. I wanted to read a little science, and my eyes fell upon — as luck would have it — Atom by Isaac Asimov. The book is an informal introduction to the world of subatomic physics, but written with a historical perspective. Asimov does not simply introduce the reader to electrons and quarks and muons and so on: he tells the history of scientific research dealing with subatomic physics and links it to studies in other fields (electromagnetism and planetary science, for instance). Even though he introduces a historical narrative into it, he is still able to explain the significance of various concepts. It is both informal and detailed. Although Asimov’s style is clear and he does a good job of explaining matters, my concentration kept leaping to my impending return to university life, and so I did not give this book the attention it deserved. I will return to it, I think.

Next Week:

  • In the Presence of Mine Enemies Harry Turtledove
  • Only Begotten Daughter, James Morrow
  • Sway: the Irresistible Pull of Irrational Behavior, Ori Brafman
Posted in Reviews | Tagged | Leave a comment

Atom

Atom: Journey Across the Subatomic Cosmos
© 1997 Isaac Asimov
300ish pages

Last week I wanted to read a little science, and my eyes fell upon — as luck would have it — Atom by Isaac Asimov. The book is an informal introduction to the world of subatomic physics, but written with a historical perspective. Asimov does not simply introduce the reader to electrons and quarks and muons and so on: he tells the history of scientific research dealing with subatomic physics and links it to studies in other fields (electromagnetism and planetary science, for instance). Even though he introduces a historical narrative into it, he is still able to explain the significance of various concepts. It is both informal and detailed. Although Asimov’s style is clear and he does a good job of explaining matters, my concentration kept leaping to my impending return to university life, and so I did not give this book the attention it deserved. I will return to it, I think.

Posted in Reviews, science | Tagged , , | Leave a comment

Darth Bane: Rule of Two

Darth Bane: Rule of Two
© 2008 Drew Karpyshyn
318 pages.

I began this year with Darth Bane:Rule of Two, the second in a yet-unfinished trilogy of books about Darth Bane, creator of the Sith order that Darth Vader and Emperor Palpatine were members of. At the end of Darth Bane: Path of Destruction, the Sith lord acquired an apprentice in the form of a young girl, Zannah. The story picks up shortly the end of Path of Destruction, where all of the Army of Darkness (the Sith) and many of the Army of Light (Jedi) have been destroyed (via events in Path of Destruction). After spending a little time here, we move ten years into the future. Bane is continuing his study of the old Sith ways to further develop his power in the Dark Side while being a mentor to Zannah. We see Bane beginning to subtly interfere in politics to bring about changes more amicable to his desires: this slow sabotage may continue until Palpatine is able to realize it in the three prequel movies. Meanwhile, one Jedi is not as confident as his brethren that the Sith have been wiped out completely. There are multiple threads: Bane’s growth as a Sith Master, Zannah’s growth as an apprentice, the Republic adjusting itself after the Sith Wars, the Jedi Council adjusting itself along with the Republic, and the lone Jedi’s quest to expose the Dark Side. The author is good at developing stories and characters and so on, but what is particularly interesting to me is the way he develops Sith philosophy. While I certainly don’t agree with it, the author actually makes it coherent. Palpatine, Maul, Dooku, and Anakin all seemed to join the dark side out of “Eh, this golden rule thing blows. How about I just give myself permission to be an ass by dressing in black and glaring?” Anakin’s descent is more complex than that, but the end result is the same. The case is different with Bane. He’s evil, but he’s principled about it. His reasons are complex, and seemingly authentic. He grows, finds meaning in Sith teachings. This is very different from the Palpatine-esque “Being evil is so much FUN!” attitude. (Zannah, however, subscribes to the “Yay evil!” school Hopefully this will change as she gets older).

All in all, a pretty good read. I enjoy the story, the characterization, the political intrigue, and especially the orbalisks. I won’t spoil anything, but they’re a really interesting idea and I’d like to see EU authors do something with them.

Posted in Reviews | Tagged , , | Leave a comment