Damned Un-English

“War, Gilbert? Are we going to have one? Shooting a few fuzzy-wuzzies out on the Frontier again?”
“In Europe, Sidney. You know, that place the other side of the Channel?”
“What do we want to get involved with them for, old chap? Full of Frogs and Proossians, ain’t it?”

Gilbert Maltravers, of His Majesty’s Ship Hindustan, has just been promoted to full lieutenant and has decided to jump ship. The Hindustan, anyway, not the Navy, though he has his doubts about his future there unless there’s a war. Gilbert has his eye on the growing submarine fleet, which appears to him to be where the action will be in the next war, not on Victorian relics. Speaking of, there are a great many Victorian relics in the Admiralty, who (in Wareham’s rendition) are utterly oblivious to the facts of modern navies: they expect the submarine crew to be armed with cutlasses for taking prizes, despite the fact that the submarines barely have room for their crews and basic equipment. Damned Un-English is set in the years leading up to the Great War, and as such contains almost no action beyond practice exercises: the book consists entirely of Gilbert learning about the service, being lectured to or lecturing others, and occasionally having stilted Regency-style conversations with his family and finance Miriam about his wicked brother or the future. Gilbert appears to be possessed by a specter from the future who not only knows that war is coming, but knows in great detail how it will play out — including the collapse of Russia and that it will be not only a general European war, but one with global scope despite a humble beginning in the Balkans. (Quote one character: “Do you think this war, if it eventuates, will be so great?”) Maltravers is generally anachronistic, and the characters he antagonizes are thoroughly caricatures. For the reader who is interested in the surfacing submarine service, there’s a wonderful amount of detail here on technical aspects, command structure, etc. As a story, though, it’s a dead loss, just lots of self-satisfied people talking to one another. I suspect if Wareham continues in the series then combat scenes will counter-balance the talking, as it did in the author’s Falling into Battle.

Unknown's avatar

About smellincoffee

Citizen, librarian, reader with a boundless wonder for the world and a curiosity about all the beings inside it.
This entry was posted in historical fiction, Reviews and tagged , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to Damned Un-English

  1. Cyberkitten's avatar Cyberkitten says:

    If you want to follow up the reality after this disappointing fiction there’s ‘A Damned Un-English Weapon – The Story of Submarine Warfare 1914-1918’ by Edwyn Gray. I’ve had it for *years* (unread naturally). It was published in 1971 so might be a *tad* difficult to get a copy though! I’m sure that there’s more up to date stuff out there.

    Oh, a picked up another Max Hennessy book today ‘The Fox From His Lair’ from my local Charity shop. It’s about D-Day and sounds like fun.

    • Ahh, yeah! I read that one a few years ago. It’s a detective story happening around D-Day. Bit of an outlier in Hennessey’s work, I think. Thanks for the reccommendation on the Gray book. Since I’m a grad student now my nonfiction options are REALLY broad: if the uni library doesn’t have it I can ILL easily. Looks like there some used copies on Amazon Uk for £10 or so.

  2. Pingback: WWW Wednesday | Reading Freely

Leave a reply to Cyberkitten Cancel reply